RongzomFan

The Dao Bums
  • Content count

    4,693
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    8

Everything posted by RongzomFan

  1. Buddhists forum vs Vedanta forum

    Because that is what was spread when Indian culture spread like the Roman empire from northwest Afghanistan to southeast islands.
  2. Buddhists forum vs Vedanta forum

    When Indian culture spread like the Roman empire from northwest Afghanistan to southeast islands, it spread the true Indian religion, Buddhism.
  3. Buddhists forum vs Vedanta forum

    Brahmanization of India took a long time. There was a good book I read on this a long time ago. Brahmins were successful at converting the masses to Brahmin authority through various strategies, including accommodation of local beliefs.
  4. Buddhists forum vs Vedanta forum

    Oh please. There was no Hinduism back in Buddha's day. The only aspects of 'Hinduism' back then were the Vedas and some Upanishads (themselves derived from Sramana) practiced by a small cult of Brahmins. Moreover if Buddhism in Buddha's day was "competing" with anything, it would be evident in the texts. But its not.
  5. Dzogchen Teachings

    This is not to say that peaceful and wrathfulls are cultural baggage. Indeed even the most New Age oriented people will experience classical grecoBuddhist seated Buddhas and peaceful and wrathful deities spontaneously if they are further down the path.....
  6. Dzogchen Teachings

    These peaceful and wrathful deities won't pop up unless you practice Shitro etc. Christians probably experience Satan. Indeed there are youtube videos of NDE's. "Avoid the sorry fate of most people, who get completely overwhelmed believing the displays of their own buddha nature to be devils coming to torture them and carry them off to hell. What a pity that would be!" Urgyen, Tulku Rinpoche (2011-12-13). Quintessential Dzogchen: Confusion Dawns as Wisdom (p. 26). Random House Inc Clients. Kindle Edition.
  7. Buddhists forum vs Vedanta forum

    Well that may be a specifically a Tibetan Nyingma thing. But indeed I pointed out before that Vajrayana sahanas have Ganesha, Lakshmi, Saraswati, Parvati etc. And all our mantras start with Om too. "Hindu" deities are not really Hindu deities. They are pan-Indic deities.
  8. Dzogchen Teachings

    What does that even mean? In trekcho, you either recognize unfabricated presence vs the conceptualizing mind. Or you don't.
  9. Buddhists forum vs Vedanta forum

    Thats an interesting question. Even in the most analytical Madhyamaka texts, Indian deities pop up. I'm sure non-Indians are more confused.
  10. Buddhists forum vs Vedanta forum

    Even two 'Hindu' doctrines like Samkhya and Vedanta are different.
  11. Buddhists forum vs Vedanta forum

    The dualism between Buddhism and Hinduism is not supported by the facts or history. For starters, there is no Hinduism in the first place.
  12. Dzogchen Teachings

    Clear light can refer to about three different things. 1. The inseperable clarity and emptiness of the mind, called kun gzhi, Buddha Nature etc. in Mahamudra. "Emptiness" in this specific context means you cannot point to clarity with your finger. You cannot find clarity, nor get rid of clarity. 2. The usual meaning of clear light is when the winds (vayus) are slowed down to a significant extent. Winds and mind are the same thing, so if the winds move subtlety that is considered "subtle mind". Clear light of sleep occurs naturally every night when the winds reconfigure. In dream yoga, you enter the clear light of sleep, and from there you enter a lucid dream. Basically the same thing as wake initiated lucid dreaming, although its combined with transmission of course. Natural death is similar.
  13. Advaita Vedanta vs Buddhism

    I don't think intellectual views have anything to do with recognizing unfabricated presence vs the conceptualizing mind. But intellectual views play an important part later on for omniscient Buddhahood.
  14. Advaita Vedanta vs Buddhism

    Greg Goode is a nobody to me. He just follows Tsongkhapa, mostly derived from introductory books by the Dalai Lama. Just because someone sets up a website, doesn't mean they are worthy of discussion.
  15. Buddhists forum vs Vedanta forum

    You've been trolled by people like xabir who 1) don't understand Buddhism and 2) are not even Indian. I am Indian, raised Hindu. Hindus consider me Hindu. My caste is munnuru kapu. My gothram is Bharadwaja. I've traveled to so many sacred sites in India on so many trips, I can't keep track. And these are not bullshit ashrams. My particular state created Mahayana in the first place (as a response to crypto-realist Abhidharma), and continued to be the preeminent site of Vajrayana. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andhra_Pradesh#Early_history
  16. Advaita Vedanta vs Buddhism

    If that is your thesis, I have to unlike your first post. Most systems are realist (Buddhist definition): http://thetaobums.com/topic/26462-being-a-realist-buddhist-definition-is-not-good/
  17. Dzogchen Teachings

    I guess you are speaking from a generic Vajrayana POV with all this transformation stuff. Which is fine by me. Dzogchen on the other hand is about recognition vs nonrecognition. Knowledge vs. ignorance.
  18. Advaita Vedanta vs Buddhism

    Correct, even in Madhyamaka, D.O. is merely a device that gets you to nonarisal/illusion.
  19. Advaita Vedanta vs Buddhism

    Correct, there is no dependent origination in Dzogchen. Instead there are the 3 inseparable wisdoms.
  20. Advaita Vedanta vs Buddhism

    This is an extremely old post of Malcolm's. There are better posts, although the search engine is broken on Dharma Wheel. My understanding is that the only similarity between Dzogchen and Madhyamaka is nonarising/illusion and freedom from extremes, which is evident even from this old post. Buddhist Dzogchenpas hold Madhyamaka as compatible with Dzogchen (with the difference being experiential vs intellectual) but Bon Dzogchenpas don't hold them as compatible at all. But then that brings up the question of what Madhyamaka everyone is following.
  21. Dzogchen Teachings

    putting on protective shades.... (•_•) ( •_•)>⌐■-■ (⌐■_■)
  22. This is about physical immortality: http://www.amazon.com/The-Khecarividya-Adinatha-Translation-ebook/dp/B000SEK1C0/ref=tmm_kin_title_0
  23. Ekam Sat & The nature of mind in Dzogchen

    Regardless of the intellectual system, one can recognize unfabricated presence vs the conceptualizing mind. Zen people do it through reading texts. Vajrayana people have direct introduction. Advaitins have satsang.
  24. I assume this thread is only about chinese traditions?
  25. Dzogchen Teachings

    Is this supposed to be sarcastic?