Simple_Jack

The Dao Bums
  • Content count

    2,425
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Everything posted by Simple_Jack

  1. Debunking a Creator

    All of these posit some sort of ontological reality. Which is why I asked how you defined relative and by what terms.
  2. Debunking a Creator

    Not in monotheistic terms. Think of it in terms of Saguna Brahman.
  3. Debunking a Creator

    But it does have enduring traditions spanning back to times of antiquity; enduring yogic traditions which are not solely quantified on the 5 senses.
  4. Debunking a Creator

    Relative how or in what way? According to who's paradigm: East or West?
  5. Debunking a Creator

    Blind belief is not a factor in accepting the tenet systems of Dharmic religions.
  6. Debunking a Creator

    What if an absolute answer is irrelevant?
  7. Debunking a Creator

    Sure not in the realm of epistemology and teleology.
  8. Debunking a Creator

    I'm just saying, I personally wouldn't put them in the category of monotheism. It's your prerogative to disagree with me.
  9. Debunking a Creator

    This can be approached differently depending on the context of the tradition. Either way, all of this is irrelevant to understanding how affliction arises. Thanks for that.
  10. Debunking a Creator

    It can't be categorized strictly as monotheism, since the devotion to Vishnu for example is synonymous with Brahman; making it closer to monism.
  11. Debunking a Creator

    Adding a fourth with Kathenotheism. Categorizations of Dharmic religions aren't as black and white as Abrahamic religions. P.S. Samkyha is for the most part an atheistic dualist school.
  12. Debunking a Creator

    I would not categorize these beliefs as monotheism, but closer to one of these three: 1. Monism 2. Henotheism 3. Monolatrism
  13. Debunking a Creator

    Yes, I agree that this is a douche statement: "Meaning you don't have to have all the religious trappings to believe in a Creator. Is that plain enough for you."
  14. Debunking a Creator

    The Vedas are considered by Hindus as shruti i.e. eternal and uncreated; considered as of 'divine origin'.
  15. Debunking a Creator

    This may not be necessary considering that a creator god is not a determining factor for Samkhya, Jainism, Mimamsa, Vaishnavism, etc. I would also put forth the idea that monotheism didn't enter the cultural sphere of Chinese thought until Zoroastrianism, Nestorian Christianity and Islam were introduced into China through the Silk Road.
  16. Neoadvaita has its flaws

    This must be a misnomer because Neo-Advaita is devoid of any path to follow.
  17. Neoadvaita has its flaws

    Not according to the Gelugpas.
  18. Neoadvaita has its flaws

    Because they are conventional designations which can be used to understand ultimate truth.
  19. Neoadvaita has its flaws

    Because it still assumes an identity.
  20. Yidams in Vajrayana

    These translations of a couple talks given the 3rd Jamgon Kongtrul Rinpoche and Khenchen Thrangu Rinpoche (of the Kagyu sect) are pretty good. They cover the three roots and and pure perception of the deity: http://www.rinpoche.com/teachings/3roots.htm http://www.rinpoche.com/teachings/mandala.htm http://www.lotsawahouse.org/tibetan-masters/khenpo-shenga/advice-on-yidam - something else worth sharing; this is not a form of Buddhist monism.
  21. Yidams in Vajrayana

    Now apply what I posted above to Cit itself, not citta.
  22. Yidams in Vajrayana

    No, my viewpoint isn't petty like that. You advised people to examine their experiences instead of blindly following belief systems as spoken by the Buddha. Shakyamuni Buddha taught that consciousnesses arise dependent on namarupa and by applying mindfulness we can notice these factors of experience are impermanent, unsatisfactory, not-self.
  23. Yidams in Vajrayana

    They're different paths because they are predicated off of different views; the latter of which is dependent origination.
  24. Yidams in Vajrayana

    Yup, most of us won't be able to achieve the body of light while still living...if we can even manage to achieve it during the dying process.
  25. Yidams in Vajrayana

    You mean like this? http://thetaobums.com/topic/32311-the-importance-of-bodhichitta-and-compassion/?p=496946 Lotus_Bitch wrote: Go tell an Advaitan that cit is conditioned by certain factors of mentality (nama) and materiality (rupa), dependent on contact to give rise to the 6 sense media and to practice by being mindful of the arising and passing of each. You will either get a confused look, be laughed at or both.