Lao Tzu

Let it be.

I know some, from what they say and do. I searched a video about her and I can not say she is a cheater, but I can tell she is not teaching the highest level Qigong.

I don't need to see them in person. (If I can, that would be perfect.) I can tell from what they say and what they do.

Thank you. I think I have enough experiences to state that. But anyway, I will try to give more details for the reasons.

I didn't say Qigong is wrong, Yes, everyone can definitely get benefit from the qigong exercises. But, one gets benefit not based on such "theories", but others. The "theories" were used to make it attactive and make people willing to give the money out. The price really doesn't worth that. So I called it a cheater. Why I am saying this? Because in all the taoism books written by the chinese immortals before, you can not find anything like these. And these conflict with the core spirit of Dao. I started to learn Qigong from 13 years old, now I am 37. At the first 5 years, I was deceived by lots of "theories" similar with this and saw lots of qigong cheaters in China. They collected huge number of money by this. Most chinese people have known this. So for the time being, the cheaters realize it is difficult to continue their jobs in China, so they came to west. They are still using these "beautiful" theories. I didn't know this untill I found this forum.

Yes, you are right. Thank you.

I knew I would fail when I post here first time. I just want to show them an idea, and hoping they will recall my words when they realize they have been deceived someday.

Thank you for your suggestions.

OKOK, I will try to do that. But you know, it is so difficult to attest my opinions. The reason is that the Qigong theory doesn't based on objectives, but feelings and subjectives. I just want to protect the innocent people from being deceived, and let the cheaters fail.

There are lots of things which we can know it is not true even if we did not try it. For such a theory, I have never seen it in the sages books, but seen it in chinese cheaters' theories.

Do not say everyone, because you do not know that. I can not show you what I know in a short time. I hope I can do that gradually.

You mean when you have the good karma to study with Master Wang, you would be certain? But how do you know there is no better one than Wang? Can you give us some logical reason why you think him the best?

You think it is silly, but I don't. So...

I have not seen even one Qigong teacher who is mentioned here be a good teacher.

I am pretty sure that the majority of the "popular" Qigong theories are made up by cheaters who are so-called Qigong masters.

I think it is just a cheater theory.

The videos you gave me here stated they are more like Kongfu masters, not Qigong masters.

Are you answering my question? If you are, please make it clearer.

How can you be so sure?

Maybe it can help to prevent people from being deceived.

In theory of Qigong, there are channels in your body, can you feel them?

If you do know what proprioception is, you would not say that.

How did I answered?

That is not the same thing as what I am talking about.

So can your duodenum be felt?