A.A.Khokhlov

"Sudden enlightenment" in daoism

Recommended Posts

Just as a side-note;  My Daoism prefers "Awareness" as opposed to "Enlightenment".

 

We become aware of the existence of the mountain and never pretend it doesn't exist.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  On 1/10/2017 at 9:55 AM, Wells said:

"Valley spirit" imo points towards the empty nature and base (ground) of the mind,

which would make it equivalent with the buddhist term of dharmakaya.

 

I like my Valley Spirit.  I rest with her oftentimes.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why are The people who don't know anything about 悟 are talking about 悟?

 

When did 悟 become a knowledge?

 

The people who know 悟 won't attack people in groups.

 

The people who know 悟 won't talk like making a war.

 

The people who know 悟 have a deep feeling and a lot of good chi.

 

Let's see what Chinese talk about 悟,not a Russian.

 

 

 

This part is from ancient Chinese

 

Too difficult to translate for me

 

悟彼蟋蟀唱。——《文选·谢混游西池诗》

慧然独悟。——《素问·八正神明论》 wise , along, 悟,have the wisdom to 悟

 

This book is nai Jin , the oldest Chinese medicine classic, Su-woon

 

 

未悟见出,意不自得。——《后汉书·张酺传》

悟已往之不谏。——晋· 陶渊明《归去来兮辞》悟 the past is not ....

闻而悟之。——明· 刘基《诚意伯刘文成公文集》 listen and 悟 it

悟前狼假寐。——《聊斋志异·狼三则》

悟大光明法。——清· 全祖望《梅花岭记》悟 the method of the big bright

 

----------

 

(3) 又如:觉悟(由迷惑而明白;由模糊而认清);悟心(悟性。对事物理解和分析的能力);悟宗(明了、会通佛理之宗旨);悟悦(因了悟而喜悦);悟理(领会道理);悟物(了悟物理);悟明(了悟真言);悟佛(了悟佛理);悟禅(参悟禅理);悟道参玄(宗教语。领会和推究宗教中玄妙之理)

 

From confused to understand

 

 

 

(4) 觉醒;觉悟。通“寤”。睡醒 [awake]

 

Awake

 

Awareness

 

行事,适有卧厌不悟者,谓此为天所厌邪?——王充《论衡·问孔》

凄凄节序高,寥寥心悟永。——江淹《杂体诗》

怛惊悟兮无闻。——《文选·潘岳·寡妇赋》

(5) 又如:悟觉(觉悟);悟门(觉悟的门径)

(6) 启发;使觉悟 [arouse]

冀悟迷惑之心。——《论衡·对作》

(7) 又如:悟主(使主上觉悟);悟发(启发)

(8) 通“晤”。相对 [meet]

过耳悟目之交。——《潜夫论·明忠》

悟言不如罢,从夕至清朝。——《文选·谢惠连·泛湖归出楼中玩月》

(9) 又如:悟对(聚会)

(10) 通“牾”。抵触 [conflict]

大意无所拂悟,…。——《韩非子》

国无刑罚,则百姓之悟相侵也立见。——《吕氏春秋·荡兵》

人不敢悟视。——《战国策·燕策三》

大忠无所拂悟,辞言无所击排。——《史记·老子韩非列传》

今人卒得鬼刺痱悟,杀雄鸡以傅其心上。——《风俗通议·雄鸡》

 

 

There are a lot of meaning about 悟

 

悟 is not a patent of Buddhism

 

悟 is from ancient China

 

 

The Daoism is from ancient China.

 

Of course, 悟 is a part of the Daoism.

Edited by awaken

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

岐伯曰:請言神。神乎神。耳不聞。目明心開。而志先慧然獨悟。口弗能言。俱視獨見。適若昏。昭然獨明。若風吹云。故曰神。

 

 

Chi-Bo said, please talk about Shen, what Shen is, no hearing, eyes are bright and the heart is open. And willing 志 first , have the wisdom to wu 悟. Can not talk by mouth. All the sight is only seeing. Like dazed, but very clear and bright . Like the wind blowing. This is What Shen is .

 

In nei Jin, we can see wu 悟 is the first step to cultivate.

 

And it described what is Shen.

 

Breathe skills are not always the first step of cultivation in ancient China.

 

Daoist cultivation changes a lot from min dynasty , practicing chi and Mco became the first step of daoist cultivation.

 

Many ancient Chinese cultures changed in the late China.

 

But in the ancient China, daoist cultivation is very different from now.

 

We can see this point from Su-woon.

Edited by awaken

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

頓悟,suddenly wu, is from zhang zon 禪宗

 

In fact, there is no 漸悟 gian-wu in zhang

 

Zhang zon talk about 頓悟 because many people we're mislead by a lot of "methods"

 

Yes, secret methods again.

 

So suddenly wu is wu

 

Zhang zon try to tell people to 悟 your real heart is the first step of cultivation

 

The secret methods are not the first step of cultivation.

 

In daoist, we can see in nei Jin and the preface of 悟真篇 that 悟 is also the first step of cultivation

 

The people who like to chase the secret methods don't think 悟 is the first step and the most important part of cultivation.

Edited by awaken

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  On 1/10/2017 at 12:06 PM, awaken said:

Why are The people who don't know anything about 悟 are talking about 悟?

When did 悟 become a knowledge?

The people who know 悟 won't attack people in groups.

The people who know 悟 won't talk like making a war.

The people who know 悟 have a deep feeling and a lot of good chi.

Let's see what Chinese talk about 悟,not a Russian.

Please calm down, being emotional harms your practice. We just having a friendly discussion here, nothing to worry about :)

 
Anyway, thank you for your posts. It once again show us 悟 is mostly related to Xing stuff (wise, awake, wisdom, work with heart etc.)
Lets wait for more ideas from fellow members.
 
  On 1/10/2017 at 12:06 PM, awaken said:

This part is from ancient Chinese

 

Too difficult to translate for me

BTW, Just curious how do you study ancient daoist texts then?

 

---

Best Regards,

Arkady

Edited by Arkady Shadursky

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is no "mind" here in this description. Dharmakaya is not mind, it's just empty, you can not say that "dharmakaya is that" because is not. If you reach dharmakaya then it will be clear what it is and you could recognize who have this and who do not understand it. You have no idea what dharmakaya is - and if you state it before yourself you will eventually find.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is some article about the difference between 

"Immediate" and "Gradual" Realization

and difference between 

  Beizong, or Northern Lineage and Nanzong, or Southern Lineage

 

http://www.goldenelixir.com/jindan/nanzong_beizong.html

 

  Quote

 

The Northern and Southern lineages have performed the historical function of providing Neidan with two exemplary modes of self-cultivation.

Beizong/Quanzhen originally did not include only Neidan among its practices. From the point of view of the history of Neidan, however, its importance consists the establishment of a major type of Neidan self-cultivation. Beizong places emphasis on Xing (one's inner Nature, which is innately perfected), and accordingly focuses on practices meant to purify one's mind ("emptying the mind," "extinguishing the mind," "ending thoughts"). The underlying doctrines make use of Buddhist notions and terms — in particular, of the doctrine of "seeing one's Nature" (jianxing).

The Nanzong mode of cultivation, instead, places initial emphasis on Ming (one's life as an individual being, including one's "destiny" or function in existence as a whole, and one's endowment of "vital force"), and focuses on practices that intend to compound the Elixir by purifying the main components of the human being: Essence, Breath, and Spirit (jingqishen). These practices follow the sequence Essence → Breath → Spirit → Dao, and consist of a process typically arranged into three main stages, the last of which lies in cultivating one's Xing, or inner Nature. The three main stages are usually called:

(1) "Refining Essence and transmuting it into Breath" (lianjing huaqi
(2) "Refining Breath and transmuting it into Spirit" (lianqi huashen
(3) "Refining Spirit and returning to Emptiness" (lianshen huanxu)

 

So may be seeing one's Nature" (jianxingis the right term for enlightenment?  :)

  • Like 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  On 1/10/2017 at 3:32 PM, SeekerOfHealing said:

There is no "mind" here ...

And the True Man (Woman too) has no mind of his/her own.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mind in Dzogchen / Buddhism doesn't mean ordinary mind but I think Wells knows that.

 

Mind = Original Awareness = Original Nature before the conditioning process.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sudden enlightenment in daoism? I wonder if it is related to this:

 

  Reveal hidden contents

 

 

The awakening described here seems similar to what is described in other traditions, flash through all memories, transcendence of time and space, life and death, etc. To me it is interesting how detailed the experience is, from a daoist perspective. Extraordinary measures are taken to prepare his body and energy, presumably to make the experience very complete and to avoid dangers from impurities.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Courious, confused, misunderstand, etc

 

I saw a better guess, 見性, Jian-xin

 

勸君門外修身者

端念思維此道心

 

Advise the people who cultivate the body outside

 

Upright the thoughts , the heart of dao

 

From Lu-don-bin

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sudden Enlightenment is the key objective of Tibetan Buddhism. The Historical Buddha, in the suttas, spoke of his numerous rebirths(500) and the practice of Perfections (Paramitas) in the cycle of births before coming to his final birth. In  the Tibetan tradition, the practice requires the total annihilation of karmas in one's current life-time so that there is no more rebirth. An Arhant is a non-Returner. The process of enlightenment requires knowing what is Ignorance, the opposite to being enlightened,  how it (ignorance) can be removed and be replaced with greater wisdom. The Buddha spoke of 7 factors of Enlightenment and can be referred to if you wish to have more information on this fascinating subject on the path to emancipation.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  On 1/11/2017 at 8:55 AM, Sudhamma said:

Sudden Enlightenment is the key objective of Tibetan Buddhism. The Historical Buddha, in the suttas, spoke of his numerous rebirths(500) and the practice of Perfections (Paramitas) in the cycle of births before coming to his final birth. In the Tibetan tradition, the practice requires the total annihilation of karmas in one's current life-time so that there is no more rebirth. An Arhant is a non-Returner. The process of enlightenment requires knowing what is Ignorance, the opposite to being enlightened, how it (ignorance) can be removed and be replaced with greater wisdom. The Buddha spoke of 7 factors of Enlightenment and can be referred to if you wish to have more information on this fascinating subject on the path to emancipation.

Sure, but it's also important to consider that many Buddhists thought achievement of Yinshen (gui xian) to be escaping the Wheel of Samsara and stopping the rebirth. Which I think is not shedding the karama, it's like permanent death..no rebirth, no chance to achieve Yangsheng. Worse than death even.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  Quote
Sure, but it's also important to consider that many Buddhists thought achievement of Yinshen (gui xian) to be escaping the Wheel of Samsara and stopping the rebirth. Which I think is not shedding the karama, it's like permanent death..no rebirth, no chance to achieve Yangsheng. Worse than death even.

 

You are follower of certain ideas and conceptions without any proof in hand same with those buddhist.

 

Escaping wheel of samsara is not attaining anything. If yangshen would be possibile Buddha would speak about it and way to realize it but yang sheng is not permanent. Entering jhanas you attain yang sheng for X milions of billions of years but then you need to go cultivate further.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  On 1/11/2017 at 11:23 AM, Wells said:

I doubt that.

Sources?

Hmm it's not doubtful at all. Many Buddhists work with Xing, Xing without Ming, result is a strong Xing, weak Ming, hence why it's possible to release a Yin spirit, because of the Yin state of the body from long time sitting, compare it to dying person..

 

What allows Yin spirit to release and cause death to regular man? Because of weak Ming - i.e. depleted yuanqi)

 

As for sources, how about Zhongliquan.

 

He mentions about it. You can check it in first chapter of Zhong lu chuan dao ji.

 

If I have a moment I'll provide a quote.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites